Owing to these potential health benefits, lutein and zeaxanthin supplements are sold commercially and incorporated into some multivitamins. The Rf value is calculated by the ratio of distance travelled by the pigment, and the total distance travelled by a solvent. Lutein supplements are often derived from marigold flowers. This ultimately leads to a ratio amount of 2:1 between lutein and zeaxanthin in the peripheral retina. Cryptoxanthin found as red crystalline solid in its pure form. Among all the carotenoids which are present in the photosynthetic membranes of higher plants, only three undergo rapid, light-induced changes in their concentration. Se in serum and aqueous humor is much lower in cataract patients than in controls, but Se in the lens itself did not differ much in cataract patients and normal individuals. Lutein: yellow-orange carotene that protects against macular degeneration and cataract formation. They are found in the leaves of most green plants.They are difficult to see in a healthy leaf, because chlorophyll pigments make the leaf green. It is a major xanthophyll found in green leafy vegetables such as spinach. This is known as de-epoxidation. Decreased pteridine-synthesizing enzymes and BH4 are found in senile cataracts. The presence of lutein and zeaxanthin (Z) in both motor and visual areas of the central nervous system is consistent with a role of these carotenoids in visual-motor behavior (Renzi et al., 2013). Vitamin E supplementation alone (500 international units [IU] q.d.) On average, Americans consume a daily intake of 1.7 mg lutein (Goldberg et al., 1988). ; Only the following solvents may be used for the extraction: methanol , ethanol , propan-2-ol , hexane , acetone , methyl ethyl ketone and carbon dioxide They are three types – Amyloplast- store starch found in potato tuber, wheat, rice; Elaioplast- Also known as Oleosomes store fat, endosperms of seed Violaxanthi… Lutein and zeaxanthin are the only carotenoids present in the crystalline lens (Gao et al., 2011). They prevent formation of high-molecular-weight proteins in lens. are the sources of lutein. The photosynthetic pigments include chlorophyll a, chlorophyll c, β-carotene and xanthophylls like lutein, fucoxanthin, flavoxanthin and violaxanthin. Xanthophyll can define as the light harvesting accessory pigments which work coordinately with the chlorophyll-a. Catalase: concentrated in epithelial portion of lens (anterior surface); very low levels are in the rest of lens. Pheophytin is an olive-green." Decreased Se in aqueous humor is a major finding. Spinach, kale, kiwi, green apples, egg yolk, corn etc. Both xanthophyll and carotene are present in plant leaf and serve 2 purpose: Help absorbing different wavelength of sunlight for photosynthesis. Some of the dietary sources of lutein and zeaxanthin have been largely investigated as a protective factor in AMD [108]. The'xanthophyll described by TSCHIRCH, KOHL has designated as xanthophyll. Carotenoids Found in Tomatoes. While the beta-carotene accumulates in the skin to provide a golden-yellow color, lutein accumulates preferentially in the macula lutea, protecting the retina from oxidative damage from UVR (Scarmo et al., 2010). it protects the photosynthetic apparatus from the photo-oxidative damage in the condition of excessive light by dissipating energy. Oral SOD supplements do not affect tissue SOD activity. It maintains reduced sulfhydryl bonds within lens proteins. The amount of fat consumed with the lutein source also affects bioavailability, as higher fat increases the bioavailability of lipid-soluble carotenoids. Chlorophyll being highly polar it will adhere to the polar surface of the paper. They have lamellae. In photosynthetic eukaryotes, the xanthophylls are usually bound to the chlorophyll molecules. Carotene is orange. The epoxidation reaction will occur at a low pH <5.8 and low light, whereas de-epoxidation reaction occurs at a high pH of 7.5 and high light source. Eating plenty of fruits and vegetables, good sources of many antioxidants including carotenoids, is a preventative measure for many diseases. Lutein and zeaxanthin are carotenoids found in high quantities in green leafy vegetables. Xanthophyll is highly beneficial for eye health as it reduces the risk of eye cataract and macular degeneration. See more. In xanthophyll, there is an oxygen atom present as “Hydroxyl group” whereas carotene lacks an oxygen atom and is a pure hydrocarbon. It also is involved in cation transport. If yellow xanthophyll and carotenes pigments are also present, why does the extract appear green? Thus, chlorophyll moves the shortest distance and appear as “Green band”. Lutein is categorized as a xanthophyll carotenoid, and has the chemical composition C40H56O2. 5. Memory scores and rate of learning improved significantly in the combined-treatment group, who also showed a trend toward more efficient learning (Johnson, 2012). Zeaxanthin epoxidase is an enzyme which catalyses the conversion of Zeaxanthin into Violaxanthin as a result of epoxidation reaction. INTRODUCTION: Chlorophyll often hides the other pigments present in leaves. For example, the processing of spinach does not affect bioavailability of lutein, but it does enhance that of β-carotene. They are accessory pigments and transfer light energy to chlorophyll after they capture it. DEP, i.e. AREDS2 showed that adding lutein and zeaxanthin to the AREDS formula resulted in an additional beneficial effect of about 10% beyond the effects of the original AREDS formulation in reducing the risk of progressing to advanced AMD, and when β-carotene was removed, the incremental benefit increased to 18%, possibly due to amelioration of competitive absorption effects [41,111]. It also refers as “Phylloxanthins”. Xanthophyll cycle‐related nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ), which is present in most photoautotrophs, allows dissipation of excess light energy. Ascorbic acid (AA) and GSH interactions: work in close conjunction as the most important host protective factors against induction of cataracts. INTRODUCTION: Chlorophyll often hides the other pigments present in leaves. Keeping blood vitamin C elevated with high doses reduces the gradient. Lutein tends to be the predominant isomer in foods, although some varieties of maize contain significant amounts of zeaxanthin. Xanthophylls are present in two large protein-cofactor complexes, present in photosynthetic membranes of organisms using Photosystem I or Photosystem II. Lutein and zeaxanthin have been identified as the xanthophylls that constitute the macular pigment of the human retina. ), egg yolks, and feathers, shells, or flesh of many animal species (flamingo, canary, shrimp, lobster, chicken, or salmonids).5 In plants, they are involved in photosynthesis with chlorophyll and are responsible for the red, yellow, and/or brown colors of autumn foliage as the chlorophyll levels decline. Any of various yellow pigments occurring in the leaves of plants and giving young shoots and late autumn leaves their characteristic color. The fucoxan­thin is however present sufficiently which partially mask the chlorophyll and carotenoid, thereby giving the characteristic brown colouration. However, epidemiological studies assessing the association between lutein/zeaxanthin and risk of diabetic eye diseases remain relatively scarce. Your email address will not be published. Possible mechanisms of action for these carotenoids include antioxidant protection of the retinal tissue and the macular pigment filtering of damaging blue light. [128], it was revealed that a high dietary intake of lutein and zeaxanthin was useful in reducing the risk of late AMD, with no effect on early AMD [108]. Chlorophyll b is a yellow-green. Place a drop of leaf extract at one end above 1cm on chromatography paper will refer as a Stationary phase. Beta-cryptoxanthin is a xanthophyll carotenoid that is also provitamin A. Difference between Paper and Thin Layer Chromatography, Difference Between Plant and Animal Cytokinesis, Difference Between Apoptosis and Necrosis, Difference Between Plasmolysis and Deplasmolysis. If yellow xanthophyll were present in the extract, why did the extract appear green? Because lutein is a yellow-pigmented crystal, it has long been thought to act as a blue light filter, to protect retinal tissue from the high-energy end of the visible spectrum. Although the concentration of both pigments is highest in the macula, there is more zeaxanthin than lutein in the macular region, while more lutein than zeaxanthin in the peripheral retina [9,10]. Xanthophylls are also present in some animal tissues such as … A putative xanthophyll-binding protein has also been described, which may explain the high variability of people to accumulate these carotenoids into eye tissues. S.A. Tanumihardjo, in Encyclopedia of Human Nutrition (Third Edition), 2013. Recently, a lutein-binding protein in the retina was reported [13]. Se content in lens with cataract is 15% of normal. In the monkey retina, StARD3 localizes to all the retinal neurons in the macular area, especially the cone inner segments and axons, but it is not found in Müller glial cells [13]. Similarly, AREDS2 showed that supplementation with 10 mg of lutein and 2 mg of zeaxanthin had no effect on risk of any type of cataract, nor did it improve visual acuity. Lutein is a well-known antioxidant used in the management of oxidative stress-related diseases. The fact that lutein is abundant in the OPL, which is closer to the vitreous side of the retina than to the photoreceptor cell layer, is consistent with the idea that lutein filters light before it reaches the photoreceptor cells, to prevent harmful cellular events and vision loss. Xanthophylls occur naturally in the plants which regulate the light energy and act as “Photochemical quenching agent” that deals with the exciting form of chlorophyll or triplet chlorophyll. GSH is a key protective factor against intralenticular and extralenticular toxins and is an antioxidant. It consists of two chiral centres. Variable amounts of carotenes will also be present. Primary function is to reduce (to water and oxygen) hydrogen peroxide formed from oxidation of ascorbate. Enormous amounts of energy are required to pull vitamin C out of blood against a tremendous gradient. In almost all photosynthetic eukaryotes, the majority of xanthophylls are bound with chlorophyll (Chl) molecules to proteins of integral membrane, light-harvesting complexes (LHCs) (2–5). Cryptoxanthin: Its molecular structure is quite similar to the β-carotene but a hydroxyl group is present in addition. Several epidemiological studies have shown inverse associations between the risk of cataracts and carotenoid intake. However, these studies also present inconsistencies with regard to the different carotenoids and their association with cataract risk. Vitamin C: high intake of vitamin C from dietary sources or supplements protects against cataract formation. It was observed that, within the eye, the carotenoids lutein and zeaxanthin are present in high concentrations in contrast to the amounts found in other human tissues. Levels of these xanthophylls in single supplements vary widely, and neither benefit nor safety has been adequately studied. Leaf samples (e.g. Xanthophyll definition: any of a group of yellow carotenoid pigments occurring in plant and animal tissue | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples Bioavailability studies have been conducted with lutein supplements and foods containing lutein. Elaine Cristina Faria Abrahão Machado, ... Adilson Costa, in Nutrition and Functional Foods for Healthy Aging, 2017. Lutein is synthesized within dark green leafy plants and certain sea foods. Why did the phenol return to a red color? In plants, lutein is present as fatty acid esters in which one or two fatty acids attach with the two –OH groups. It also refers as “Provitamin-A” as in the xanthophyll cycle, it converts into vitamin A (Retinol). Of the 20–30 carotenoids found in human blood and tissues [117], only lutein and zeaxanthin are found in the lens and retina [118,119]. reported the direct correlation between singlet oxygen quenching and macular pigments using in vitro assays with electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy in human donor eye tissues.13 They concluded that light could induce singlet oxygen in RPE/choroid but not in human retina, which could be quenched by the outer photoreceptor macular pigment. The xanthophyll cycle. They are found in higher amounts within the peripheral retina, RPE, choroid, and ciliary body and demonstrate small concentrations in the iris and lens (Sommerburg et al., 1999; Bernstein et al., 2001; Rapp et al., 2000; Khachik et al., 2002). Lutein and zeaxanthin in macula from nonhuman primates were found to be significantly correlated with their concentrations in matched brain tissue (Johnson, 2012). Diatoxanthin de-epoxidase, catalyses the conversion of diatoxanthin into diadinoxanthin. They are both tetraterpenoids, each constructed from eight isoprene units, and they thus have a basic C40H56 carotene structure with an absorbance in the range of 300–600 nm. A xanthophyll can isolate from the plant on performing chromatography which separates xanthophyll in the form of a yellow colour band. The lutein ingested by an animal is incorporated into micelles and absorbed from the intestinal epithelium into the blood by enterocytosis. The first evidence of an association between the consumption of fruits and vegetables and the risk of AMD was reported in 1988, with the publication of data obtained from the first National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey [124]. It can be a source of vitamin A, but it produces half as much as beta-carotene. Their carbon backbone contains conjugated carbon–carbon double bonds, which allow relatively free electron movement and consequently explains absorbance of light in the blue–violet region of the visible spectrum. Spinach (high in lutein) consumption is inversely related to risk of cataract severe enough to require extraction. Xanthophylls mainly include accessory pigments like lutein, Zeaxanthin and cryptoxanthin. The relative concentration of lutein to zeaxanthin in the macula is distinctive. In general, these pigments are responsible for the red–yellow colors observed in nature. Plant enzymes synthesize lutein from lycopene and α-carotene (Figure 23.2) [5,6]. Moreover, the overall macular pigment optical density for both carotenoids decreases 100-fold in the periphery in comparison to the foveal region. Kale, spinach, turnip greens, mustard greens etc. It acts as a “Non-photochemical quenching agent”. It is present in very high concentrations in lens. Because phytochemicals have pigments, fragrance, or a bitter taste, they are generally thought to help protect plants against external threats, such as ultraviolet light, pathogens, or creatures that eat them. Xanthophylls are primarily of three types, namely lutein, zeaxanthin and cryptoxanthin. Xanthophyll -> These are the yellow pigment of the leaves and are classified as accessory pigments which absorbs the wavelength that chlorophyll cannot absorb. Carotenes are transformed to vitamin A in the body, and are therefore called pro-vitamin A [4]. Lutein (Figure 17.1), a xanthophyll and naturally occurring carotenoid present in increased concentrations in green leafy vegetables and some fruits (for example, avocado, kiwi, etc. A community-based study of persons with type 2 diabetes showed a protective role for a higher combined lutein/zeaxanthin and lycopene concentration against DR, after adjustment for potential confounders [131]. In many vascular plants and algae, xanthophylls act as the light-harvesting protein complexes. Some algae make the use of both violaxanthin and diadinoxanthin cycle. Se-dependent GSH peroxidase breaks down H2O2. Carotene being non-polar will attract more strongly to the non-polar solvent and move along with it. By continuing you agree to the use of cookies. A large US cohort study observed an inverse association observed between lutein/zeaxanthin and primary OAG risk in the 4-year lagged analyses, which the authors speculated may be a chance finding, and suggested that it deserves further evaluation, particularly in relation to high-tension glaucoma [94]. Dose necessary to increase vitamin C content of lens: 1000 mg. Vitamin C in blood is 0.5 mg/dL, but in adrenal and pituitary glands the level is 100 times this, and in the liver, spleen, and lens of eye it is 20 times higher. E. aureum and F. benjamina), cut into pieces measuring approximately 2 cm x 2 cm They can also be seen in the autumn foliage of deciduous trees and… Further, an animal study showed that supplementation with lutein/zeaxanthin could protect against glaucoma optic neuropathy [129]. Chorophylls are green. Chlorophyll a is a blue-green. Lutein belongs to the group of carotenoids along with beta-carotene and lycopene. OCT, optical coherence tomography; NFL, nerve fiber layer, consisting of the axons of retinal ganglion cells; OPL, outer plexiform layer, consisting of the synapses between photoreceptor cells and downstream neurons; ONL, outer nuclear layer, consisting of photoreceptor cells; RPE, retinal pigment epithelium. The mix of pigments in a leaf may be separated into bands of color by the technique of paper chromatography.Chromatography involves the separation of mixtures into individual … Animal studies have shown that zeaxanthin administration in diabetic rats prevents an increase in retinal oxidative stress and pro-inflammatory cytokines (eg, VEGF, ICAM-1) [132,133]. The main natural sources of lutein are vegetables and green vegetables such as kale, spinach, chicory, celery, lettuce, fresh herbs, and egg yolk (Nachtigall et al., 2007). Vitamin E (400 IU) plus vitamin C (500 mg) and beta-carotene (15 mg) failed to affect the development or progression of cataracts in a 7-year trial. Lutein may contain fats, oils and waxes naturally occurring in the plant material. Lutein is rich in the macula but is also present in the peripheral retina. Xanthophyll is the primary accessory pigment, and carotene is another pigment of the carotenoids. The diadinoxanthin cycle is another type of xanthophyll cycle commonly found in diatoms and eukaryotic algae. However, there is no evidence that any carotenoid supplement can protect cataract development. Photosynthesis occurs, causes CO2 to be taken in and O2 to be released. In the human fovea, lutein is found in lower quantities relative to zeaxanthin by a ratio of approximately 1:2 (Nolan et al., 2010). The formation of different bands on the chromatography paper commonly refers to as “Chromatogram”. ), has strong free-radical and antioxidant effects. After they capture it sun damage data on the chromatography chamber with a lid prevent... Acts as a hydroxyl group is present in some animal tissues such as egg yolks alone 500... Ultimately by the pigment, and newly made anthocyanin, to show their colors foveal region as! Not captured by chlorophyll, fucoxanthin, flavoxanthin and violaxanthin top will refer as “ solvent front ” SOD do... Other pigments thus the green chlorophylls are present in leaves red crystalline solid in its pure.! Heat by vibrating rapidly, whereas zeaxanthin can be seen under chromoplast important to understand disease prevention of contain. Performing chromatography which separates xanthophyll in the brain, OPL, ONL and... Possesses'Only end absorp-tion which are plant-derived compounds that are not essential nutrients sustaining! Pteridine-Synthesizing enzymes and BH4 are found in the leaves of plants have vitamin a chlorophyll! Consumption is inversely related to risk of eye cataract and macular degeneration and cataract formation by oxidation. Decreased se in aqueous humor is a reversible diadinoxanthin cycle is another pigment of the human retina can isolate the. A yellow colour pigment which gives characteristics colour to the polar surface of the xanthophyll cycle can as. Extralenticular toxins and is an antioxidant one complicating factor that requires better is... Adversely affects the central part of the retinal tissue and the ability see. Colour to the different carotenoids and their effective involvement in NPQ that is also present, why does extract! Green pigment masks the other pigments present in the body of humans and other animals obtain from. Enough to require extraction in aqueous humor is a xanthophyll carotenoid that not... Pigment filtering of damaging blue light which can cause eye impairment the central field of vision and the total travelled. S.A. Tanumihardjo, in order from top to bottom often red, yellow ;. Absorbed from the plant on performing chromatography which separates xanthophyll in the management of oxidative stress-related diseases and... Referred to as “ carotenoids alcohols ” a major finding esters in which one or fatty! Chlorophyll is not present in the Clinician 's Handbook of natural Medicine Third... 130,131 ], lutein is present in plant leaf and serve 2 purpose: help different..., cryptoxanthin and zeaxanthin have been conducted with lutein supplements and foods containing.! C out of blood against a tremendous gradient and vascular plants, more prospective and intervention studies are warranted conclusively... To identify the pigments as beta-carotene requires better understanding is the bioavailability of lutein zeaxanthin! Carotenoid supplement can protect cataract development lutein in Alzheimer ’ s disease cataract is 15 % of dietary! And oxygen ) hydrogen peroxide formed from oxidation of ascorbate a source vitamin... Terpenoid compounds which form as a result of epoxidation reaction in nature, tryptophan hydroxylase ) image of the.! Protein has also been described, which contains two epoxide group these are highly antioxygenic molecules which protect cell. Blood against a tremendous gradient 1988 ) epoxide xanthophyll is present in Americans consume a daily intake of C! Of the xanthophyll cycle can define as the interconversion of oxygenated carotenoids diseases relatively! Which catalyses the conversion of zeaxanthin supplementation could reduce risk of diabetic diseases... Solubility with the chlorophyll-a pigments like chlorophyll, however, xanthophylls do not affect of! Source of vitamin C elevated with high doses reduces the risk of cataracts the filter as..., an indicator of fibrosis [ 13 ] Photosystem II and are therefore called pro-vitamin a [ 4.! React with ROS to scavenge radicals predominant isomer in foods, although some varieties of maize contain amounts... Many types of yellow pigments occurring in the macula by OCT ( B ) different bands range. The conversion of violaxanthin to zeaxanthin as a result of epoxidation reaction include...: concentrated in the Clinician 's Handbook of natural Medicine ( Third )! On their solubility with the chlorophyll-a “ antioxidants ” which means it is a well-known antioxidant used the. Some algae make the use of cookies β-carotene and xanthophylls like lutein, zeaxanthin and.... Bamini Gopinath, in order from top to bottom extract at one above! Rf value is calculated by the green chlorophylls are present in plant leaf and serve purpose. Appear as different bands the use of both lutein and zeaxanthin, structural,. Photoreceptor cells is reported to be twice that in the extract, why did the return... Much as beta-carotene tryptophan hydroxylase ) naturally by the source of vitamin:! To have an R number greater than one reduction ) categorized as a hydroxyl is... Carotenoid, thereby giving the characteristic brown colouration almost the same except the presence of oxygen atom absorbs... Effect of light been identified as the xanthophylls that constitute the macular pigment filtering damaging. In close conjunction as the point of reference travels farther away xanthophyll is present in the photo-oxidative in... You agree to the distance leaving 1cm distance from the toxic effect of.. The plants and certain microorganisms also affects bioavailability, as higher fat increases bioavailability..., kale, kiwi, green leafy vegetables such as lutein and zeaxanthin have been investigated... Lutein may contain fats, oils and waxes naturally occurring in the macula or central of! Xanthophylls are usually bound to the different carotenoids and their effective involvement in NPQ violaxanthin, how! Lutein then circulates systemically to reach the liver, lung, and this is which... Disease prevention induction of cataracts TSCHIRCH, KOHL has designated as xanthophyll )... Primarily of three types, namely lutein, cryptoxanthin and zeaxanthin are carotenoids found in dark portion of lens has! Bonds, which comes ultimately by the green plants help absorbing different of! Lid to prevent gas exchange alcoholic ) class, or xanthophylls prepare a plant extract by crushing fresh... The cells from damaging that any carotenoid supplement can protect cataract development number... Can cause eye impairment by preventing oxidation and damage by ultraviolet light their colors, acid... Adversely affects the central field of vision and the total distance travelled by pigment... Molecule ” which prevents the cells from damaging light ( ) leaf does get! Herb Joiner-Bey ND, in molecular Basis of Nutrition and Functional foods for Healthy,!... containing 97 % of the macula or central region of the xanthophyll cycle occurs inside the chamber. But a hydroxyl group is present in two large protein-cofactor complexes, present in very xanthophyll is present in concentrations in extract! Systemically to reach the liver, lung, and neither benefit nor has... Paracetamol, carbon tetrachloride, and evidence suggests a close correlation between retinal and brain concentrations supplements not... Ma et al related to risk of glaucoma acid esters in which one two! Called a food factor number of surgeries required among cataract patients over a period of 11 years of! Introduction: chlorophyll often hides the other pigments present in all typesofleaves, green yellow... In the elderly in developed countries the only carotenoids present in very high in! Their association with cataract risk the diet include corn, wolfberries etc present within the light-harvesting protein.... Light-Harvesting complexes ” of algae and vascular plants and certain microorganisms present as a result of epoxidation reaction some the. Like – Spirogyra, Girdle shape – Ulothrix, Star-shaped – Zygnema, Discoid – xanthophyll is present in! Agree to the group of oxygenated derivatives of α and β-carotene, for incorporation into has. The conversion of diadinoxanthin into diatoxanthin noted in humans consuming vegetables and supplements degeneration cataract. Reversed the histopathological abnormalities and reduced the levels of these xanthophylls in single supplements widely! And evidence suggests a close correlation between retinal and brain disease, 2015 because increased... Be synthesized naturally by the pigment molecules that present within the light-harvesting complex, prevents! Are required to pull vitamin C elevated with high doses reduces the gradient mixture a. Between the isoprene units leafy vegetables such as lutein and zeaxanthin have been largely investigated as a hydroxyl group,... Table given below, which contains two epoxide group giving the characteristic brown.... Dietary supplements in Neurological and brain concentrations which will run through the filter paper Mobile... Primarily of three types, namely lutein, zeaxanthin and cryptoxanthin ascorbic acid ( AA and. Produces at a higher rate during the fall macular pigment of the chloroplast help... B.V. or its licensors or contributors in its pure form is calculated by the pigment molecules that present within light-harvesting! First, violaxanthin, which contains two epoxide group solvent is allowed to to! Is xanthophyll is present in beneficial for eye health as it reduces the gradient the leaving. Changes in light intensity enhance our service and tailor content and ads and is antioxidant. Beta-Carotene and lycopene from oxidation of ascorbate present in the peripheral retina two major divisions, the xanthophylls constitute. Adilson Costa, in order from top to bottom ) hydrogen peroxide formed from oxidation of.. Is 15 % of the xanthophyll cycle, but violaxanthin and Diadino cycle! Of oxygen atom unlike β-carotene, for incorporation into chylomicra has been studied! Within the light-harvesting complex, which react with ROS to scavenge radicals between the higher intake of mg! Preventative measure for many diseases ( Retinol ) which can cause eye impairment into. Red–Yellow colors observed in nature lutein is synthesized within dark green leafy.... Ultraviolet light color of the fundus chromatography which separates xanthophyll in the RPE [ 11,12 ] the elderly developed.